Logic Apps Agent Loop + MCP: Two Bugs Worth Knowing About

I spent the long weekend pushing Logic Apps MCP server capabilities further than I had before — and hit two bugs worth documenting. Both are filed. If you're building in this space, save yourself the debugging time.

Context

If you've been following along, the MCP server and BODMAS Agent are covered in the previous posts. This post is just about what broke when I wired them together.

Bug 1 — Intermittent duplicate key error at tool registration

What happens

The Agent Loop fails with a BadRequest before making a single MCP call:

HTTP request failed: 'An item with the same key has already been added. Key: {tool_name}'.

The key referenced in the error — BasicArithmeticMCP, ExtendedArithmeticMCP, whatever you name it — appears exactly once in the workflow definition. There is no actual duplicate in the JSON.

What makes it particularly frustrating to diagnose

It is intermittent. Some runs fail, others succeed with identical configuration and identical input. No changes between a failing and a succeeding run — same workflow, same expression, same everything.

I spent a good chunk of Saturday convinced I had a naming conflict in my JSON. I didn't.

Load test

I fired 5 to 10 parallel requests at the Agent Loop as a mini stress test. It failed — the duplicate key error appeared across multiple runs in the batch.

Sequential calls with proper spacing between them worked fine.

What you can't do

The Agent action has a default retry policy, but it does not help here. A BadRequest (400) is not treated as a transient error — the retry policy targets server-side failures (5xx), not client errors. So even with retries configured, the duplicate key error causes an immediate terminal failure. There is no clean in-workflow workaround.

Bug 2 — MCP Connector does not support OAuth

What happens

Both the MCP server and the MCP client are Logic Apps Standard. When OAuth is configured on the MCP server side, the workflow doesn't trigger at all — it never reaches the Logic App. The connection gets corrupted at design time with the OAuth setup, and no run is created.

Tools don't load but you can save the workflow.

You get a 502 bad gateway error when you push a request.

The same endpoint called directly from Postman with a valid bearer token works fine.

Why it matters

To get the Agent Loop working, the MCP server has to run with either anonymous authentication or key-based authentication. OAuth simply does not work with the built-in MCP client connector.

Current state

Both issues are filed on the Logic Apps GitHub repo:

Agent Loop: "An item with the same key has already been added" when using McpClientTool

The issue covers both bugs with full workflow JSON, reproduction steps, and screenshots. If you've hit either of these, add a reaction or comment — the more signal on the issue, the better.

What works in the meantime

• Set "type": "anonymous" in the McpServerEndpoints authentication block in host.json — removes the OAuth blocker for dev and demo use


• Accept the intermittent failure rate on the Agent Loop and re-trigger manually when it hits — not a fix, but the success rate is high enough to keep building and testing

Both issues are filed. If you hit either of them, the GitHub issue is the right place to add signal.