Is Code Really a “Social Text”? A Skeptical Review of Critical Code Studies

TL;DR: A sharp academic review takes aim at Mark C. Marino’s Critical Code Studies (MIT Press, 2020). The verdict? Lots of hype, some interesting cases, but little real code analysis. If you’re a programmer who rolls your eyes at postmodern buzzwords, this one’s for you.

📖 The Book in a Nutshell

Marino argues that code has escaped the programmer’s dungeon and entered mainstream culture. Code is no longer just a tool – it’s a social text whose meaning changes with every new reader (lawyers, poets, activists, etc.). The book promises a literary‑style reading of software, drawing on postcolonial, feminist, and queer theory.

🔍 What the Review Says (Boris Orekhov, Digital Humanities, 2026)

Me, Boris Orekhov - a digital humanities scholar - is not impressed. My main gripes:

• Overblown claims – “Audience of code has exploded!” Really? When was the last time a climate change debate hinged on reading source code? I call it cherry‑picking.




• Case‑dropping, not analysis – We get anecdotes: a protest sign in C, a feminist PHP app, the Transborder Immigrant Tool. But actual code examination is superficial. A license phrase (“no warranties”) is noted as tragicomic – that’s about it.




• Lost the plot – Marino sets up a story about two programmers competing for a job, then… never finishes it. This happens every 10‑15 pages.




• Postmodern catechism – The book wears its ideology on its sleeve (postcolonial, queer, feminist). Fine, but it substitutes slogans for rational argument. Systematic methodology? Nowhere.




• Missing prior work – My own 2015

  
  
  
  
  
  

  
  
  
  📚 Cite the Original Review
  

  
  
  

  
  
  
  APA
  

  
  
  

  Orekhov, B. (2026). Рецензия на книгу Марка К. Марино «Критические исследования кода» [Review of Critical Code Studies, by M. C. Marino]. Цифровые гуманитарные исследования, (1), 114–121. .

  
  
  

  
  
  
  BibTeX
  

  
  
  
  
  
  
  

  CODE Kopieren

  @review{Orekhov2026code,
  
    title = {Рецензия на книгу Марка К. Марино «Критические исследования кода»},
  
    author = {Орехов, Борис},
  
    year = {2026},
  
    doi = {10.31860/cgi-2026-1-114-121},
  
    journal = {Цифровые гуманитарные исследования},
  
    number = {1},
  
    pages = {114--121}
  
  }
  
  

  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

  
  
  
  💬 Let’s Discuss
  

  
  
  

  Have you read Critical Code Studies? Do you think code has a “social life” beyond its function? Drop your take in the comments – and share this post if you want more honest, no‑BS book reviews for devs.

  
  
  

  
  
  
  CriticalCodeStudies #BookReview #SoftwareStudies #Programming #DigitalHumanities
  

  Vollständiger Original-Bericht

  Ausführliche Details, Code-Beispiele & Hersteller-Stellungnahme auf dev.to.

  ↗ Original-Artikel auf dev.to lesen